Comparative Assessment of Extraneous Matter Contamination and Juice Quality in Sugarcane Harvested Using Manual and Mechanical Loading Systems at Blairmont Estate, Guyana
Comparative Assessment of Extraneous Matter Contamination and Juice Quality in Sugarcane Harvested Using Manual and Mechanical Loading Systems at Blairmont Estate, Guyana
Sugarcane delivered to processing factories contains variable quantities of non-stalk material that may influence cane quality and factory handling. This study evaluated two field systems at Blairmont Estate, Guyana: manual cutting followed by hand loading, and manual cutting followed by mechanical loading using a Bell loader. A randomized complete block arrangement with three field replications per system was reported for a second-ratoon crop of cultivar DB96-33, approximately 51 weeks old, in Follow Smith Field 51. Composite samples were collected from each punt and separated into cleaned cane and cane retained with extraneous matter (EM). Trash, tops and soil were quantified, while juice Brix, Pol and purity were determined. The mechanical-loading system had higher descriptive means for trash (3.52%), tops (4.78%) and soil (1.26%) than hand loading (0.98%, 1.79% and 0.14%, respectively); however, reported treatment tests were not significant for trash (p = 0.1061), tops (p = 0.2559) or soil (p = 0.4070). This study reported factorial ANOVA identified system effects for Pol (15.305% manual; 13.563% mechanical loading; p = 0.0281) and purity (78.812% and 72.230%; p = 0.0464), while Brix did not differ significantly (p = 0.2712). Cane category effects were also reported for Pol (p = 0.0419) and purity (p = 0.0259), but not Brix (p = 0.7659). No interaction was detected for any juice-quality variable. These findings indicate that the tested mechanical-loading system was associated with lower mean Pol and purity, although inference is limited by three field replicates, one field and cultivar, and unresolved pairing in the original factorial model. The experiment did not measure commercial sugar recovery, factory extraction or operational costs. A larger, multi-field study with punt-level repeated-measures analysis and standardised analytical protocols is required before estate-wide recommendations are made.